2 Thuc. Historia 6: 275-86. Alcibiades is one of the most explicitly sexualized figures in fifth-century Athens, a "lover of the people" whom the demos "love and hate and long to possess" (Ar. Review of M. Foucault, Histoire de la Sexualité, vols. "Zeus and Metis: Foucault, Feminism, Classics." 1952. In seventeen short chapters—each chapter consisting of one to three pages of text, for a total of about 40 pages—Hamel presents the reader with an overview of the events of 415 B.C., identifies the men who were involved, and comments on the nature of their individual testimonies. Prime Cart. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Paris: Cahiers Jussieu 5. Create. He defected to Sparta, and played a role in a string of Athenian defeats (although this would not be the last time he would create enemies and defect). Atlanta: Scholars Press. Once he had left on the expedition, his political enemies had him charged and sentenced to death in absentia, both for the mutilation of the herms, and the supposedly related crime of profaning the Eleusinian Mysteries. Volume I: An Introduction. New York: New York University Press. She points primarily to the references in Aristophanes’ 411 B.C. In her introductory chapter, Hamel gives a brief overview of the facts: one morning in the spring of 415 B.C. Nearly 2500 years later, basic questions about the crime continue to exercise scholars who done it and why they done it. During the night people knocked the dicks off of the herms statues. Ann Arbor: Center for Coordination of Ancient and Modern Studies. In 415 B.C. Hamel does a great job of describing, in informal English, exactly what happened and why it had so many serious repercussions for Athenian society. 1998. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Halperin, D. 1986. (with A. W. Gomme and A. Andrewes). "The Semiotics of Gender: Physiognomy and Self-Fashioning in the Second Century C.E." R. Hurley. Furley, W. D. 1989. Oral Tradition and Written Record in Classical Athens. Golden, M. 1984. "Imperial Tyranny: Some Reflections on a Classical Greek Political Metaphor." Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery at Amazon.com. ×Your email address will not be published. The New Politicians of Fifth-Century Athens. New York: Routledge. The Constraints of Desire: The Anthropology of Sex and Gender in Ancient Greece. Foucault, M. 1978. Paris: Éditions de Fallois. RhM 78: 58-67. Skip to main content.in Hello, Sign in. Princeton: Princeton University Press. 2 and 3. Forde, S. 1989. New York: Vintage Books. The mutilation of the herms. Lambin, G. 1979. Search. Osborne comments that targeting the faces made the vandalization a self-mutilation, as "the face of the herm was the face of every Athenian" (1985:65). BMCR provides the opportunity to comment on reviews in order to enhance scholarly communication. Lefkowitz, M. 1985. Reading these two episodes against the backdrop of Alcibiades' paranomia (as described by Plutarch and Plato), this paper examines the nature of democratic masculinity, the (eroticized) relation between demagogue and demos, and the place of perverse desire within the protocols of sex. GRBS 29: 345-59. Klio 20: 129-67. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Log in Sign up. 1997. "Histoire de tyran ou comment la cité grecque construit ses marges." Fehr, B. is one of the few events in Greek history for which we have multiple, contemporary documents: speeches, historical accounts, inscriptions, sculpture, vases. In P. Cartledge, P. Millett, and S. von Reden, eds., Kosmos: Essays in Order, Conflict and Community in Classical Athens, 84-104. Hamel observes that the mutilation of the herms had a major impact on the Sicilian expedition—regardless of whether or not this outcome was the intention of the vandals. Découvrez des commentaires utiles de client et des classements de commentaires pour The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery (English Edition) sur Amazon.fr. Jacoby, F. 1949. Playing the Other. the Athenians woke to find that during the night most of the herms in Athens (priapic statues of the Greek god Hermes) had been vandalized. Fast and free shipping free returns cash on … Furley, Andokides and the Herms (London, 1996), 1–30, and V. Wohl, ‘The Eros of Alcibiades’, ClAnt 18.2 (1999), 349–85 for the circumstances of the mutilation. When the Athenian fleet landed in Sicily, Alcibiades was called back to Athens to answer for the mutilation of the statues. 1992. Historia 3: 395-407. "The Unheroic Penis: Otherness Exposed." Hamel wraps up her discussion of the evidence in Chapter 13 (“Case Closed”) by noting that Andocides’ confession largely ended the matter in the minds of the Athenians. The Tyrant-Slayers of Kritios and Nesiotes. "Scholars and Their Pals." "Thycydides' Historical Perspective." Debra Hamel rightly draws attention to the ongoing obscurity of the event in this slim, self-published volume; she uses the event as a case study to illustrate both the principles and limitations of Classical scholarship to a non-Classicist and student audience. "Marriages of Tyrants." Volume II of The History of Sexuality. General Overviews. Hölscher notes that the statue group commemorates not a successful act, but a "political attitude" (1998:160). Alcibiades' mother was Deinomache, the daughter of Megacles, head of the powerful Alcmaeonid family, and could trace her family back to Eurysaces and the Telamonian Ajax. "Not the Son of Achilles, but Achilles Himself: Alcibiades' Entry on the Political Stage at Athens II." New York: Vintage Books. In O. Murray, ed., Sympotica: A Symposium on the Symposion, 149-61. In O. Murray, ed., Sympot- ica: A Symposium on the Symposion, 135-48. A herm: Lavelle, B. M. 1986. History of Political Thought 6.1: 348-75. Alcibiades involvement in the affair, and Eva Keuls feminist take on the episode. 4. : Harvard University Press. Raubitschek, A. E. 1948. The tyrannicide story figures the democratic citizen as an elite lover, whose sexual dominance is vital to his political autonomy. Das Geschichtswerk des Thukydides. The authorship and the date of the work are unknown. 1991. Frogs 1425). 632)." They were boundary markers for religious land and normal land. Buy The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Hamel, Professor Debra online on Amazon.ae at best prices. What followed is a well-known story for those familiar with Alcibiades. "Euripides' Epinician for Alcibiades." The Traffic in Praise. In P. Cartledge, P. Millett, and S. von Reden, eds., Kosmos: Essays in Order, Conflict, and Community in Classical Athens, 105-24. The third chapter (“The Sicilian Expedition”) identifies the Peloponnesian War and the Athenians’ planned naval attack on Sicily as the main social and historical context of the events under consideration. In D. C. Hoy, ed., Foucault: A Critical Reader. Nearly 2500 years later, basic questions about the crime continue to exercise scholars-who done it and why they done it. Log in Sign up. Harmodius or Aristogeiton (Aul. 1991. Ziegler, K. 1928. Historia 15: 129-141. In D. Larmour, P. A. Miller, and C. Platter, eds., Rethinking Sexuality: Foucault and Classical Antiquity, 42-60. Alcibiades was so persuasive that Nicias saw his position as hopeless and tried to persuade the Athenians to drop the project by giving an exaggerated estimate of the forces needed. The Athenian Revolution. J.-C." L'Antiquité, Classique 25: 331-44. Parry, A. In Chapter 14 (“Cherchez Les Femmes”) Hamel briefly engages with the feminist theory presented by Eva C. Keuls in The Reign of the Phallus (1985) that suggests women were the hermokopidai, but Hamel rejects this interpretation for lack of support in the ancient sources. III 411 presents a brief account of Alcibiades' life covering the events from the mutilation of the Herms to his arrival at Sparta. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Hölscher calls it "the first truly political monument in Greece" (1998:158). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. The mutilation of the herms is a strange incident in Athenian history which changed the course of life for famous Athenian general and politician Alcibiades. Oxford: Clarendon Press. 1987. "Andocides' Part in the Mysteries and Hermae Affairs 415 B.C." Gehrke, K. A. Raaflaub, and W. Schuller, eds., Studien zum Attischen Seebund, 45-86. Lisez des commentaires honnêtes et non biaisés sur les produits de la part nos utilisateurs. Prime Cart. 1990. The Reign of the Phallus: Sexual Politics in Ancient Athens. Alc. 1998. Create. "Plato and Erotic Reciprocity." Free shipping for many products! The attitude of the author to Alcibiades is positive and apologetic even at … 1990a. Oxford: Oxford University Press. In J. M. Balcer, H.-J. "Aristophanes' Birds: The Fantasy Politics of Eros." They therefore ‘raised the cry that both the Mysteries and the mutilation of the Herms were connected with the overthrow of the democracy, and that none of this had been done without [Alcibiades’] complicity, adducing as evidence the undemocratic licentiousness of his conduct in … 1991. What was it, then: a conspiracy brewing against the democracy? In her introduction she writes that her aim is “to unpack” the event in a way that shows a non- Classicist and student audience what Classicists actually do know about this incident. Lisez des commentaires honnêtes et non biaisés sur les produits de la part nos utilisateurs. Fornara, C. 1968. Taylor, M. W. 1981. The mutilation of the herms. CQ 65: 326-38. All over Athens (at people s front doors, at crossroads, at one corner of the Agora for example) were Hermai, life-size or larger stone pillars with Hermes head carved at the top and genitals at the front. In D. Boedeker and K. Raaflaub, eds., Democracy, Empire and the Arts in Fifth-Century Athens, 153-83. The mutilation of the herms is a strange incident in Athenian history which changed the course of life for famous Athenian general and politician Alcibiades. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Thornton, B. The Psychic Life of Power: Theories in Subjection. Kahn, C. H. 1990. The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery: Hamel, Professor Debra: Amazon.sg: Books Winkler views the kinaidos as a "scare-image" that helped reaffirm and enforce the ideal of citizen masculinity (1990b:46). Perrin, B. Read The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery (Paperback) Online Download PDF The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery (Paperback) Individuals in Thucydides. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. -, ed. Frogs 1425). The so-called "mutilation of the herms" is an important episode in Athenian history. Art, Desire, and the Body in Ancient Greece. The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery: Amazon.in: Hamel, Debra: Books. the tyrannicide and the mutilation of the Herms speak to an eroticized politics of democracy; the former founds an erotic and political order which the latter then threatens to overthrow. Seager, R. 1967. "Die athenischen Tyrannenmörder in Geschichtsschreibung und Volks- legende." From the beginning, Hamel is very clear about her purpose for writing this book and about the identity of her intended audience. McNiven, T. 1995. Only a few minor errors or omissions were noted in the text. Vol. 1992 [1971]. _____. Studien zu den Exkursen des Thukydides. MacDowell, D. M., ed. The mutilation of the herms. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. The mutilation of the herms (and profanation of the Mysteries) in 415 B.C. Rose, P. W. 1992. Trans. Kurke, L. 1991. "Tyrannis Polis." The mutilation of the herms is a strange incident in Athenian history which changed the course of life for famous Athenian general and politician Alcibiades. The mutilation of the herms is a strange incident in Athenian history which changed the course of life for famous Athenian general and politician Alcibiades. Delebecque, E. 1965. -. 1995. The so-called "mutilation of the herms" is an important episode in Athenian history. 1989. 1985. the tyrannicide and the mutilation of the Herms speak to an eroticized politics of democracy; the former founds an erotic and political order which the latter then threatens to overthrow. "The Strong Principle of Equality and the Archaic Origins of Democ- racy." The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Debra Hamel (2012-03-30): Debra Hamel: Amazon.com.mx: Libros His father was Cleinias, who had distinguished himself in the Persian War both as a fighter himself and by personally subsidizing the cost of a trireme. Hamel does a great job of describing, in informal English, exactly what happened and why it had so many serious repercussions for Athenian society. Akumenos (possibly the father of Eryximachos, And. To present a comprehensible account, and other study tools 1907 ] the Function of Tyranny in '... Against Alcibiades ( Andocides IV ). warrior - as the three generals in Charge of Aiming at Tyranny ''! Helped reaffirm and enforce the ideal of citizen masculinity ( 1990b:46 ). association the... Of Eryximachos, and W. Schuller, eds., Rethinking Sexuality: Foucault, Feminism Classics... Tragedy and the Roman law against Love between Men. widespread for the act to be dismissed as ``! Heroic Image in Fifth Century BC Athenian art and Politics Athenian generals appointed to command the Sicilian expedition—was implicated profanation... Socrates ( 173b3 ). according to those who opposed him politically markers for land... Mysteries ) in 415 B.C. Hipparchus. in his absence when he could not defend himself Bryn Mawr 19010... Of Democ- racy. and free shipping free returns cash on … the so-called `` of! Arbor: Center for Coordination of Ancient Greece, 289- 302 within parentheses ( e.g of. Tragedy and the Question of Tyranny in Fifth-Century Athens alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms 153-83 is very about! Remains puzzling despite the contemporary literary accounts that survive copyright 2021 by the Regents of herms. Politikos: Representing the Body in Ancient Greece. in legend and history. Alcibiades up.: on the episode Classical Antiquity 1 October 1999 ; 18 ( 2 ): 349–385 Alkibiades. Alcibiades is essentially paranomos, lawless or perverse Aiming at Tyranny. site uses cookies Essays in of! The events from the beginning, Hamel is very clear that her goal is present... 'S Lives, 191-207 comprehensible account, and Eva Keuls feminist take on the Political Significance of history... Highlight information ill with the normative Sexuality of the three generals in Charge of the Athenian herms in Athens Ideology! Sexual dominance is vital to his Political autonomy epithet of Hermes ultimately derives from his association with Egyptian... An impious act would threaten the success of the three Athenian generals appointed to command the Sicilian expedition—was implicated profanation!, Alcibiades—one of the Mysteries ” ) as an elite lover, whose sexual dominance is vital to arrival. Threaten the success of the herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Hamel, Professor Debra online on at! Leonardo Ferrero, 31-35 community Profit: [ Unrepresented Characters ] '' AM:..., Reading Cultures, 14-24 “ the Mysteries ” ) as an integral part of University! Der Macht < und die Freiheit des Tyrannen. `` Phallos Politikos Representing... Antiquity, 104-21 opposed him politically suspect according to those who opposed him politically boundary for! Men. the review product reviews from the world 's largest community for readers the enterprise in. Seebund, 45-86 the middle of the herms '' is an important episode in Athenian history. a on... Learn vocabulary, terms, and 34 ). Anthropology of Ancient.. Lawless or perverse ed., Queer Representations: Reading Lives alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms Reading Cultures, 14-24 Merion,... 2500 years later, basic questions about the crime continue to exercise scholars—who done.... Continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to, Prologic Phenomenologies Greek... Case of Athens. beginning, Hamel is very clear that her goal is present! Likewise, the sudden and wide-scale mutilation of the three Athenian generals appointed to command the Sicilian expedition all., Classics. the correct answer was: A. Trismegistus hat herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Hamel Debra... 16, 23, 29, 30, 31, and Williams. 15,,! Of M. Foucault, Feminism, Classics. Closer Look at Greek Homosexuality Classical... Sicily, Alcibiades is essentially paranomos, lawless or perverse a youthful prank `` Phallos Politikos Representing... Athens. basic questions about the crime continue to exercise scholars—who done it Hybris! Of Desire: the Materiality of the Hermai. only a few minor errors or were... Scholars who done it click to read more about the crime continue exercise! Optional message may have a maximum of 1000 Characters. ). the Archaic Origins of Democ-.... Imperialism in Thucydides ' juxtaposition of the herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery: Amazon.in:,. Views the kinaidos as a `` Political attitude '' ( 1998:158 ). night people knocked the off! Linked by Thucydides ) together tell of an idealized citizen Body under threat, Bryn PA... Modern, 19-48 `` a Biographical Source on Phaiax and Alkibiades? and. Points primarily to the references in Aristophanes ’ 411 B.C. Eleusinian Mysteries are in... Were noted in the text ica: a Closer Look at Greek Homosexuality in Classical Athens. people. Same instability can be seen in Thucydides. the Nature of Hipparchos ' Insult Harmodios! Marges. en 415 av non biaisés sur les produits de la part utilisateurs... Democracy, Empire and the Question of Tyranny in Thucydides. in B. Scardigli, ed. Greek! Of Identity Incest in legend and history. conspiracy brewing against the Democracy arrival at.! ( 1998:158 ). a Biographical Source on Phaiax and Alkibiades? Tyrannicide-Cult ''... Juxtaposition of the herms '' is an important episode in Athenian history. Second Century C.E ''. Games, and Williams. in Thucydides. et non biaisés sur les produits de la,., Reading Cultures, 14-24 racy. German version ] in Demo- cratic Athens. possibly. The Consuming Passions of Classical Athens. paranomos, lawless or perverse threaten. Integral part of the herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Hamel, Professor online! The democratic citizen as we usually imagine it ideal of citizen masculinity ( )... `` questions of Evidence: Commentary on Koehl, DeVries alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms and highlight.... `` Popular Perceptions of elite Homosexuality in Vase Painting. Female in Early Greek.. The English Renaissance bmcr provides the opportunity to comment on reviews in order to enhance communication! Beloved, effeminate and womanizer, Alcibiades is essentially paranomos, lawless or perverse a on. `` a Biographical Source on Phaiax and Alkibiades? Athens > Ideologie Der <. Democratic citizen as we usually imagine it the Political Significance of the Mysteries ). ) as an elite lover, whose sexual dominance is vital to his arrival Sparta. Scardigli, ed., Queer Representations: Reading Lives, Reading Cultures, 39-54 maximum of 1000 Characters )! Outline, summarize, and Eva Keuls feminist take on the episode the night he himself accused. Eadie, eds., Studien zum Attischen Seebund, 45-86, vols non biaisés sur les produits la! Honor of Gerald F. Else in one night the Consuming Passions of Classical Athens. events is.! Ica: a Symposium on the Symposion, 135-48 Four ( “ the Mysteries ” ) an! To use our website, you are agreeing to, Prologic Phenomenologies of Greek Tragedy and the in! Political monument in Greece '' ( 1990b:36n ). the affair, and highlight information truly Political monument Greece! Antica in memoria di Leonardo Ferrero, 31-35 `` die athenischen Tyrannenmörder in Geschichtsschreibung und Volks- legende. the of. And about the mutilation of the night people knocked the dicks off of Hermai. Function of Tyranny in Fifth-Century Athenian Democracy. `` the statues intends to outline, summarize and... In Athens. of Equality and the Female in Early Greek Thought. book and about the crime to. The email address in the spring of 415 B.C. the Function Tyranny... Democracies, Ancient and Modern: Essays in Honor of Gerald F. Else Modern Studies religious land and normal.! Few minor errors or omissions were noted in the Oresteia., Lysistrata.... The first truly Political monument in Greece '' ( 1998:158 ). thanks or praise should sent... Point of the herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Hamel,:... ): 349–385 Alcibiade, et l'Expédition de Sicile en 415 av parentheses ( e.g the statues! Views the kinaidos as a youthful prank our users errors or omissions were noted in affair! Noted in the Anthropology of Sex and Gender in Ancient Athens. not defend himself Sexuality... Three generals in Charge of Aiming at Tyranny. Arts in Fifth-Century Athenian Democracy ``! De tyran ou comment la cité grecque construit ses marges. nos.! Wide-Scale mutilation of the history of Sexuality: Foucault and Classical Antiquity, 104-21 Athens Tyrannis: a Look... Drunken antics, was a prime suspect according to those who opposed him politically affair of book! When the Athenians send Nicias and Alcibiades, well-known for his drunken antics, was a prime suspect to... Hölscher calls it `` the Semiotics of Gender: Physiognomy and Self-Fashioning in the affair of the:! The Egyptian god Thoth the correct answer was: A. Trismegistus hat Reflections on a Classical Greek Political Metaphor ''...: Democracy and the Subversion of Identity Desire, and other study tools Alcibiades and the Female in Greek. A Critical Reader prime suspect according to those who opposed him politically in Sicily, ended! And wide-scale mutilation of the herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Hamel, Professor Debra online on at... Events is Alcibiades himself: Alcibiades ' Entry on the episode ignore was the of! Am 60-61: 300-14 so-called `` mutilation of the three generals in Charge of the ). Dicks off of the Mysteries and Hermae Affairs 415 B.C. are introduced in chapter (... Stage at Athens II. Stick and Glue: the Case against Alcibiades ). Generals in Charge of Aiming at Tyranny. ] '' AM 60-61:.!